about-failure-feature-cadus_projekt_rojava-2015_07-fb7892b5

About failure

At some point it seems, it had to hit us as well. For quite a time now representatives of other aid organisations active in North Syria kept asking us how we managed to get over the border of Turkey and Syria so easily.

Now our team had to experience where this question actually came from. Arriving at Suruc, the path was supposed to be the same as every time: first stop at the regional administration to file for a border crossing within the scope of humanitarian aid, wait a little while, have a lot of tea with the officials present. But after that, up until now, always followed the crossing of the border.

This time the situation had changed. Unfortunate that our team arrived one day after the terrible attack in Ankara. Horrible that the south east of Turkey finds itself in a climate of fright and horror. Upsetting that many of those people engaging in aid for refugees fleeing from Syria, or helping people on the spot, were arrested or even disappeared altogether.

Consequence for our team: This time it meant waiting – for a long time. Resulting in a rejection by the Turkish administrations. The same administrations that manage the state-run refugee camps so restrictively that inhabitants rather return over the border to Kobane then to stay in Turkey.

In short, even to bring in the Department for Foreign Affairs (Auswärtiges Amt), the German Embassy in Ankara and the support of many members of the German Parliament (Bundestag) did not get us anywhere near Kobane. Instead, the Turkish administration applied a very well known strategy: First they asked for many many papers and contacts, then, having received all those, getting our hopes up for a positive decision, they pushed the final judgement on to the superior authorities. We played along this game for a few days. Enervating and exhausting for the team on site, knowing all the time that just across the border there are people waiting for the training promised. Just as enervating for the back-up office in Germany, as, to be honest, there is a lot of better things to do than running after Turkish administrations.

The result: The regional supreme authority pushed the decision on to the regional coordinator of UN-OCHA (Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs). Home run, we think: They should be the ones to be keen on having us continue our work in Syria. Far wrong, though! Neither the intervention of members of the German Parliament (Bundestag), nor the embassy, nor our cooperation partners in Syria are able to accomplish a positive outcome to our request. Statement of the UN-coordinator: After all, he wouldn't even know us and a verification on his part wouldn't exactly take month, but at least weeks and besides, we didn't even take part in the Cluster-Meetings in Gaziantep. You can imagine our anger and disappointment about his reaction and therefore this is a topic we will definitely comment on more in detail in another blog post.

After 8 days our team eventually had to leave Turkey without actually having given any training to anyone.

The state that at the moment is receiving billions of euros from the EU, so the refugees they take in wouldn't come to Europe, treats these refugees so badly that they rather return to war zones than staying in Turkey. And the same state doesn't even leave those people willing to help to the people desperately in need of it.

And eventually, exactly THE organisation that was established to coordinate the various aid organisations willing to help, blocks our way. And this shouldn't let you get cynical?

But cynicism or not, we will not let this stop us and our work. Even, if of course, we prefer to deal with actual and effective aid programs than bureaucratic barriers, we will continue to put our energy into helping people in Syria and not just leaving them to themselves.

Refugees welcome – fight causes of flight… even if it seems like everyone is getting in your way!

Published
Author: by Jan Kout

By CadusPR

  • 18 months ago, when we first started, everything happened very quickly. The kid needed a name. We didn't waste a lot of time and thought, too much had to be done... events went head over heels. Anyway, content was more important than the cover. 

    Published On: August 29th, 2015
  • Die zeitgleich geführten Offensiven verschiedener kurdischer Kampfverbände auf beiden Seiten der syrisch-irakischen Grenze sind vorerst abgeschlossen, beziehungsweise weit genug von unseren üblichen Einsatzorten entfernt. Das hieß für uns, dass sich das nächste Medic-Team letzte Woche auf den Weg machen konnte.

    Published On: February 14th, 2016
  • Die Ereignisse in Paris haben auch uns am Wochenende wieder sprachlos zurückgelassen. Ebenso wie die Anschläge in Beirut, Baghdad, im Yemen, in Taiz, in Mokha, in Nairobi; und diese Liste ist nicht abschließend.

    Published On: February 14th, 2016

Stay informed about our missions, events and humanitarian emergency aid topics – with our newsletter!

Newsletter registration

 

I consent to the processing of my personal data (e-mail)

I agree to receive the newsletter

Spende für unabhängige humanitäre Nothilfe

Deine Spende macht es möglich, dass wir unsere Ressourcen und Fähigkeiten dort einsetzen wo sie am dringendsten gebraucht werden.